During a career that spanned parts of five seasons – the 2020 campaign was shortened and then canceled by the COVID-19 pandemic – Kittle, of Millville, a catcher, earned all-conference first-team honors three times, was named to the second team once and was selected for the Division III All-Region Third Team as a senior.
In the NCAA era, since 2014, Kittle ranks No. 1 in eight career categories – 43 doubles, 22 home runs, 122 runs batted in, .608 slugging percentage, 33 hit by pitch, 720 putouts, 874 chances and 49 passed balls – and is second in three categories – 467 at-bats, 112 runs and 168 hits. He led the team in runs scored once, RBIs four times, doubles twice, home runs three times, batting average once, hits once, on-base plus slugging once, total bases twice and slugging percentage twice.
Kittle started 133 of the 135 games he played in. During that time, the Wildcats won 74 games and lost 68, reaching the NEAC playoffs four times, where they finished second in both 2017 and 2018. The 2017 team set a program single-season win mark of 25 that still stands.