Wildcats Show They're More Than 'Just' Athletes

Lacrosse team members landscape the front yard of a Habitat for Humanity-built house before its homeowners move in. From left: Austin Callahan, Roman DeCenzo, Devin Page, Kevin Ronayne III, Leighton Acevedo, Nick McGowan, Andrew Tavarez, Tyler Hannan, John Dolezal and Nate Campisi.

Penn College Magazine Fall 2025, Volume 34, Number 2

MB

by Matt Blymier

Assistant Director of Athletics/Athletic Communications & Compliance

A KEY PART OF PENN COLLEGE ATHLETICS’ mission is providing students the opportunity for self-discovery through hands-on leadership and civic responsibility – to be more than just athletes. 

Throughout the academic year, student-athletes actively participate in a wide array of community service, embodying the department’s commitment to making a positive impact in the community. These events range from neighborhood clean-ups and youth sports clinics to volunteering for local nonprofits and organizing fundraising drives for charitable causes. 

In 2024-25, athletic programs completed 2,701 hours of community service and raised a little over $21,000 for various charities. The men’s lacrosse team led the charge with 17 initiatives and nearly $13,000 raised. The team’s value on community service is so great that they take an entire day during their Spring Break trip to Virginia and North Carolina to volunteer their time with charities in those areas. 

“Service is the first pillar of our program, and we put a huge emphasis on giving back,” men’s lacrosse head coach Jordan Williams explained. “If we have the capability to give, serve or volunteer, we want our men to do just that. Our Spring Break community service event is typically most guys’ favorite memory of that trip, regardless of how tired they are from playing games and traveling. 

“Getting to see the impact, whether in our local community, around campus, or when we serve in a different state, allows our men to see the value of service and how much of a difference we can make with our actions.”

Setting Records

In addition to a record-setting 2024- 25 year in competition – including three conference championships, two conference runners-up, 62 all-conference selections and eight all-region honors – Penn College student-athletes had their performances in the classroom recognized at an all-time level, as well.

The department finished the academic year with a collective 3.28 cumulative grade point average, which included 264 dean’s list selections and 115 perfect 4.0 GPAs combined between both the fall and spring semesters. Thirteen athletic programs finished the year with a 3.0 or higher GPA. 

At the national level, five Wildcats earned their respective sport’s top academic honor as Scholar All-Americans, while at the conference level, 178 student-athletes were named United East or Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference Scholar-Athletes. 

A record four Penn College student-athletes earned one of the United East’s top academic honors, the Elite 20 award. The award was created in 2022 and is presented to the student-athlete who holds the highest grade point average among the teams that qualified for the conference postseason. Walt Heiser ’25 was honored for men’s lacrosse; Peyton Mussina ’25 received the honor for golf; Landon Reeder ’27 earned the honor in men’s basketball; and Alec Rees ’25 earned the award in men’s cross-country. 

Kayleigh Miller ’25, a two-time recipient of the Elite 20 award – for cross-country in 2024 and women’s basketball in 2022-23 – was named the United East Senior Scholar-Athlete, which recognizes a senior who truly represents the student-athlete model by performing in competition, in the classroom and around the community.

Walt Heiser ’25

Peyton Mussina ’25

Landon Reeder ’27

Alec Rees ’25

Kayleigh Miller ’25

Wildcat Athletics

Livingston Cross ’25

Men’s Basketball

Penn College advanced to the United East semifinals for the first time in program history. Gavin Barrett ’25 and Livingston Cross ’25 were named to the United East first team for the second straight season, and Cross, who led the country in double-doubles, earned D3Hoops.com all-region honors.

Gigi Parlante ’28

Women’s Basketball

The Wildcats reached the conference postseason for the third consecutive season after a 12-4 United East record. Rachel Teats ’25 earned her program-record third all-conference honor, while Gigi Parlante ’28 became the first player in the NCAA era to earn both first-team honors and the conference’s Rookie of the Year.

Noah Hunt ’25

Wrestling

Penn College won its first Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference championship with an astounding eight individual champions. Noah Hunt ’25 became the second Wildcat in program history to earn a berth to the NCAA Division III Championship tournament after finishing third at the NCAA Division III Region 2 Championship. He was one of a program-record five wrestlers on the podium at regionals: Carter Davis ’28 earned fourth, Isaac Cory ’27 took fifth, Nick Woodruff ’27 finished sixth, and TJ Martin ’27 placed eighth.

Peyton Mussina ’25

Men’s Golf

Penn College three-peated as United East champions and had five players selected to the all-conference team. Peyton Mussina ’25, Will Orwig ’25 and Gunner Redmond ’26 were named to the first team, while Logan Gawlinski ’27 and Brady Handy ’27 earned third-team honors. Mussina also picked up his second all-region award and made the cut at the NCAA Division III Championship for the second time before finishing 49th. He became the first Penn College student-athlete in any sport to earn NCAA All-American honors.

Madison Herriman ’25

Softball

The Wildcats qualified for the NCAA Division III Regionals for the second straight season after finishing runner-up at the United East tournament. Mackenzie Weaver ’25 was named United East Pitcher of the Year for the second time in her career and earned a second-team all-region nod. Madison Herriman ’25 was named to the UE first team, while Payton Crawford ’28 and Mackenzi Tice ’28 earned second-team honors, and Grace Lorson ’25 landed on the third team.

Mason Nester ’25

Men’s Lacrosse

Penn College played in the United East championship game for the second straight season and finished runner-up. A program-record 12 players earned all-conference honors, led by Elliott Dotson ’28, who was named both the Rookie of the Year and Offensive Player of the Year. Dotson was joined by Austin Callahan ’26, Walt Heiser ’25, Owen Kupsey ’28, Aidan McFalls ’27 and Ryan Twist ’27 on the first team. Levi Borkowski ’28, AJ Dotson ’26, Will Ehret ’27, Mason Nester ’25, Jake Small ’27 and Ian Stambaugh ’28 landed on the second team.

Shawn Townsend ’27

Baseball

The Wildcats reached the United East postseason for the eighth time since joining the conference in 2015. The team achieved five all-conference honors, with Dallas Griess ’27 and Shawn Townsend ’27 earning first-team honors. Jaydon Goebel ’27 and Matt Munoz ’27 were named to the second team, and Levi Purnell ’28 was named to the third team and the conference’s Rookie of the Year. Townsend also earned all-region honors.